A most pleasingly atmospheric rendition of the tale, noirishly photographed and moodily set, this is the version which probably would have delighted Conan Doyle the most. There is one important plot change which enables the beautiful Alice Brandt to enjoy both a larger role and a more intriguing part in the proceedings. This change also builds up the parts of Dr Mortimer and Lord Charles, yet at the same time provides a nice introduction to the is-he-sinister or is-he-a-good-guy Barrymore, deftly played here by Fritz Rasp.
Despite the sting of its well-developed story, the spellbindingly atmospheric direction and the engrossing performances delivered by the entire cast, many fans may find this version somewhat disappointing. For at least three reasons: As in the novel, the part played in the narrative by Sherlock Holmes, though vital, is minimal. And in this version, not only has no attempt been made to enlarge his role, if anything both writer and director do their best to minimize it. Holmes does not even make his entrance for half-an-hour, and when he does finally appear, he has his back to the camera. It is Fritz Odemar, as Dr Watson, who receives the more favorable camera angles. And there is a purpose in this. It is Watson, not Holmes, who figures as the main protagonist of The Hound of the Baskervilles. For the bulk of the narrative, Holmes disappears. It is Watson and Lord Henry (Peter Voss) who take up the running. The movie is almost over, before Holmes closes in on the villain. And even so, this is not the obsessed, self-important Holmes we are accustomed to see taking charge. Another problem is that the title hound itself does not figure a great deal in the action, a downgrading which will undoubtedly rate as another major disappointment for fans. And finally, it could be argued that the script gives too much attention to Conan Doyle's red herring, the escaped convict, and not enough to the real villain.
This said, it must surely be admitted by all, that Odemar's interpretation of Watson—intelligent, charming, level-headed, courageous and resourceful—is much closer to Conan Doyle's conception than either the bungling, inveterately stupid Nigel Bruce or the self-effacing Ian Fleming.
One other player deserves special mention: Erich Ponto (Dr Winkel in The Third Man) who seems exactly right for Stapleton. A difficult part, superbly played.
- JohnHowardReid, imdb
清水版在b站上看两分钟剪辑 其余的就是在各种地方做…但男主是真的帅 跟after差不多
想不通一集ova就能讲明白的内容非要做成两个多小时的总集篇，这个剧场版瞬间拉低了原作一个档次，属于是没事找事，说得好听是剧场版，新内容其实只有最后的20分钟，最终凶手终于被逮捕，小女孩终究打不过壮汉，小户川房间里是一只黑猫，确实也不存在什么诱拐绑架，伏笔基本都填了，最后的大团圆结局虽然不错，但这个作品80%以上都是tv版的老画面，所以要看的话可以只看最后25分钟。官方电影实体福袋里好像暗示最后是柿花救了小户川，幸运对幸运，最后男主更胜一筹，也算再次点题了，广播剧里的老板娘也没有死，最后ED显示老板娘只是受伤住院了，剧场版的ED确实明示了很多东西，需要稍微注意一下
美丽的花店女老板vs智慧的心脏科女医生
2022年2月6日
评价是不如看一遍TV版 也就最后三分钟新内容吧
没想到这片还有点尺度 本来以为是普通青春片呢 为啥总是浪子配好女呢 这种玛丽苏应该是女编剧写出来的吧 那为啥会傻不拉叽地觉得浪子会为一个女孩收心呢 还很喜欢用家庭原因合理化男主的浪 从布里奇顿到这部 欧美女权应该是很强的吧 为啥还能写出这样的剧情？这么看国内偶像剧男的最起码大多数是干净的 而且男女主都没有啥过多的精神交流 就上两次床而已 一个很浪的男主就能爱上女主？咋爱上的根本都不知道 还不如暮光之城男主因为听不到女主想法和血好闻所以才好奇去了解 然后英雄救美吊桥效应产生爱情等 我发现现在这年头连玛丽苏都在倒退 欧美竟然跟国内一样 连玛丽苏都不会拍了 国内是工业糖精 国外是机械做爱 男女主没有互相救赎也没啥磨难考验和成长 就莫名其妙爱的不行？爱情要不要这么廉价啊？好烦 想看个浪女配处男的
丘比特竟然是WIFI，“战神”下凡谈恋爱。
话说是不是一定要先听完广播啊 没懂前面为什么要搜集调查😵
冲着女主cp两个美女颜值去看的，国外是不是真的好喜欢黑金啊哈哈哈
说实话我一直是不喜欢加泰罗尼亚长相的，看剧照本来也觉得男主不戳我！但！是！！两个人化学反应太好了！！而且男主的身材妈呀！！最后就是直戳我的x癖！！！比jamie更！！！女主也是一眼普通结果越看越好看的类型！而且她的屁股也太好看了吧！！！剧情是真的挺傻的，但是这个cp真的好好磕，个人审美太喜欢啦！！不喜欢的人应该觉得挺无聊的，反正我三天看了两次
什么莫名其妙的爱情剧情和不能在一起的理由……西班牙的高中生爱情又尬又扯
看得我好痛苦😖今天的新宿TOHO还热得要命。如果是看完动漫过了很久可能还好，我前天才看完动画今天看这个，如坐针毡。一个半小时前一个小时20分钟都在复述剧情，而且是通过每个人说话的方式来把13集的动画再过一遍。抱着看假黑猫跟小户川的最终对决的心情去看，就来句“这是运的对决！”结束了？？虽然很明显是小户川赢了，结尾图片闪现里也有假黑猫被逮捕的新闻，但是这太水了吧！！票价居然跟imax的奇异博士一个价！！离了个大谱😅
还真挺落后的爱情片。男主有钱人女主普通人 女的觉得融入不了这个家庭 到妈妈告诉她爱就要勇敢去追 最终有情人终成眷属 十几年前的套路了 看下来没什么意思 而且大段都是男女主的床戏 欧洲学生的众生色相倒是可以看看。其实有钱是一个很省事的设定 想干嘛就干嘛想去哪就去哪不需要有金钱门槛 整个故事的发展脉络也会简单很多 但这个神三角家庭的富有很架空 衣服啥的都没有很明显的贵气 所以更显得这个故事没什么意义。最后说“我是来换一条新的”倒是有点东西ww
不好看，没诚意，就男女主颜值扛打，其他都垃圾死了……男主如果尝试演一些LGBT类电影估计比这个火
真烂哪 之后+五十度灰+烂大街的各种桥段 如果现实生活中遇到这样的人还是赶紧跑吧 不然连自己怎么死的都不知道
纯纯弱智玛丽苏涩情片了……但本土狗还是看完了，为什么呢，大概是因为难得碰到欧美青春剧有正点帅哥还不是gay的了55555
补足了tv版一些没交代的事情，比如黑猫在车上放gps。总的来说是给看过tv版的人回忆用的，没看过的就是一头雾水。不是一部合格的剧场版，结尾挺甜
全程靠男女主颜值撑下来的，咱就是说也不知道讲了个啥，不能以严肃论调看这里的情情爱爱，只能说爽了就好
给人的感觉挺轻松的，蛮好看的 ，内容不错，轻松小喜剧
真是够垃圾的 全片最好看的是那个attempt rimming镜头哈哈哈哈
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
